FAA source text, reformatted for reading. Page boundaries and paragraph numbers are retained.
APPENDIX B. ASSESSMENT METHODS FOR FAILURE CONDITIONS
B.1 Assessment Methods. Various methods for assessing the causes, severity, and probability of failure conditions are available to support experienced engineering and operational judgment. Some of these methods are structured. The various types of analysis are based on either inductive or deductive approaches. Probability assessments may be qualitative or quantitative. Descriptions of some types of analysis are provided below and in SAE ARP 4761.
B.1.1 Design Appraisal. This is a qualitative appraisal of the integrity and safety of the system design.
B.1.2 Installation Appraisal. This is a qualitative appraisal of the integrity and safety of the installation including the evaluation of any deviations from normal, industry-accepted installation practices, such as clearances or tolerances, especially in the case of modifications made after entry into service.
B.1.3 Failure Modes and Effects Analysis. This is a structured, inductive, bottom-up analysis that is used to evaluate the effects on the system and airplane of each foreseeable element or component failure. When properly formatted, the FMEA should aid in identifying latent failures and possible causes of each failure mode. SAE ARP 4761 provides methodology and detailed guidelines, which may be used to perform this type of analysis. In SAE ARP 4761, an FMEA could be a “piece-part” FMEA or a “functional” FMEA. For modern microcircuit-based line replaceable units and systems, an exhaustive piece-part FMEA is not practically feasible with the present state of the art. In that context, an FMEA may be more functional than piece-part oriented. A functional FMEA can lead to uncertainties in the qualitative and quantitative aspects, which can be compensated for by a more conservative assessment such as—
• Assuming all failure modes result in the failure conditions of interest,
• Careful choice of system architecture, or
• Taking into account the experience lessons learned on the use of similar technology.
B.1.4 Fault Tree or Dependence Diagram Analysis. These are structured, deductive, top-down analyses used to identify the conditions, failures, and events that would cause each defined failure condition. They are graphical methods of identifying the logical relationship between each particular failure condition and the primary element or component failures, other events, or combinations thereof that can cause it. An FMEA may be used as the source document for those primary failures or other events.
