FAA source text, reformatted for reading. Page boundaries and paragraph numbers are retained.
5.4 Compliance with § 25.1309(c).
5.4.1 Section 25.1309(c) requires that information concerning unsafe system operating conditions be provided to the flightcrew to enable them to take appropriate corrective action in a timely manner, thereby mitigating the effects of the condition to an acceptable level. Any system operating condition that, if not detected and properly accommodated by flightcrew action, would significantly contribute to, or result in, a hazardous or catastrophic condition, should be considered an unsafe system operating condition. Compliance with this requirement usually relies on the analysis identified in paragraph 5.3.1 of this AC, which also includes consideration of crew alerting cues, required corrective action, and the capability of detecting faults. Section 25.1309(c) further requires that the applicant design the systems and controls, including indication and annunciation, to minimize crew errors that could create additional hazards (in compliance with § 25.1302). The required information may be provided by an indication and/or annunciation whose forms and functions meet the requirements of § 25.1322 or may be provided by other dedicated means of information,2 or may be made apparent by the inherent airplane responses. The required information also depends on the degree of urgency for recognition and corrective action by the crew.
5.4.2 When a system provides failure monitoring and indication, the system reliability should be compatible with the safety objectives associated with the system function for which it provides that indication. For example, if the effects of having a system failure and not annunciating that failure are catastrophic, the combination of the system failure with the failure of its annunciation must be extremely improbable. The loss of annunciation should be considered a failure condition in and of itself, due to its impact on the ability of the flightcrew to cope with the subject failure. The subject failure condition should be classified as major unless the applicant can show otherwise. In addition, the applicant should assess unwanted operation (for example, nuisance alerts). The failure monitoring and indication should be reliable, technologically feasible, and economically practicable. Reliable failure monitoring and indication should use current state-of-the-art technology to maximize the probability of detecting and indicating genuine failures, while minimizing the probability of falsely detecting and indicating non-existent failures. Any indication to the flightcrew should be timely, obvious, clear, and unambiguous.
5.4.3 In the case of airplane conditions requiring immediate flightcrew action, a suitable warning indication must be provided to the flightcrew in accordance with § 25.1322, if not provided by inherent airplane characteristics (for example, buffeting). In either case, any warning should be rousing and should occur at a point in a potentially catastrophic sequence where the airplane’s capability and the flightcrew’s ability still remain sufficient for effective crew action to prevent the catastrophic outcome. For
2 The terms alert, annunciation and indication are used interchangeably throughout this AC. These terms have been defined and used in different ways, and their definitions may change in the future. Refer to AC 25.1322 and other relevant ACs for the definitions of these terms and their specific application.
