FAA source text, reformatted for reading. Page boundaries and paragraph numbers are retained.
2.2.2.11 Error Tolerance that considers adverse effects of foreseeable errors during
the airplane’s design, test, manufacture, operation, and maintenance.
2.3 Highly Integrated Systems. In 1998, the ARAC System Design and Analysis Working Group raised a concern regarding the efficiency and coverage of the techniques used for assessing safety aspects of highly integrated systems that perform complex and interrelated functions, particularly through the use of electronic technology and software-based techniques. The concern was that design and analysis techniques applied to deterministic risks or to conventional, non-complex systems might not provide adequate safety coverage for more complex systems. Thus, other assurance techniques have also been applied by the FAA and applicants to these more complex systems. These techniques included development assurance using a combination of process assurance; validation and implementation verification techniques; and structured analysis or assessment techniques conducted at the airplane level if necessary or across integrated or interacting systems. The systematic use of these techniques increases confidence that errors in requirements, designs, or implementation, and integration or interaction effects have been adequately identified and corrected. Applicants should continue to emphasize the fail-safe design concept discussed in paragraph 2.2 of this AC in the development and assurance of highly integrated systems.
2.4 Use of Both Qualitative and Quantitative Methods. Considering the above developments, as well as revisions made to § 25.1309, this AC includes additional approaches, both qualitative and quantitative, which may be used to assist applicants in their 14 CFR 21.20 obligations to show compliance with system safety regulations, considering the whole airplane and its systems. This AC also provides guidance to assist applicants in determining when, or if, particular analyses or development assurance activities should be conducted in the frame of the development and safety assessment processes. See AC 20-174 and the industry documents listed in paragraph 1.4.5 of this AC for additional guidance. In summary, both qualitative and quantitative methods are used in practice, and both may be necessary to some degree to support a compliance finding. The analytical tools used in determining numerical values are intended to complement, but not replace, qualitative methods based on engineering and operational judgment. See appendix B of this AC for guidance on available qualitative and quantitative methods for assessment of failure conditions.
