FAA source text, reformatted for reading. Page boundaries and paragraph numbers are retained.
3.2.4.1 Intent of the Term “Extremely Improbable.”
3.2.4.1.1 The FAA’s objective of using this term in the system safety regulations has been to describe a condition (usually a failure condition) that has a probability of occurrence so low that it is not anticipated to occur in service on any transport category airplane to which the standard applies. However, while a rule sets a minimum standard for all the airplanes to which it applies, the FAA’s compliance determinations are limited to applications for individual type certificates. Consequently, in practice, the applicant should provide a sufficiently conservative showing that a condition is not anticipated to occur in service during the entire operational life of all airplanes under a type certificate application being assessed.
3.2.4.1.2 The means of showing that the occurrence of a failure condition is extremely improbable varies widely, depending on the type of system, component, or element that must be assessed. The FAA does not consider failure conditions arising from a single failure to be extremely improbable, unless the operational or environmental conditions under which the failure must occur to produce a catastrophic event are in and of themselves extremely remote, or the physics of a theoretical failure is so implausible that the FAA can agree it is not anticipated to ever actually occur. (See paragraph 7.3.2.) Thus, probability assessments for catastrophic outcomes normally involve conditions arising from multiple failures. Both qualitative and quantitative assessments are used in practice, and both are often necessary, to some degree, to support a conclusion that a failure condition is extremely improbable. Generally, performing only a quantitative analysis to show that a failure condition is extremely improbable is insufficient, due to the variability and uncertainty in the analytical process. Any analysis used as evidence that a failure condition is extremely improbable should include justification of any assumptions made, data sources, and analytical techniques to account for the variability and uncertainty in the analytical process.
3.2.4.1.3 Wherever part 25 requires that a condition be extremely improbable, the compliance method—whether qualitative, quantitative, or a combination of the two—along with engineering judgment, should provide convincing evidence that the condition is not anticipated to occur in service when the airplane is produced in accordance with the approved type design, is operated in accordance with approved operating procedures, and is maintained in accordance with approved maintenance procedures.
